The origins of jambalaya include West Africa, Spain, and France. The meat-free variations of gumbo rely much more on a variety of greens for its body, including mustard greens, spinach, and turnip greens.

The final dish, seasoned with everything from garlic to oregano and cayenne pepper, is served rice that has been cooked separately. Creole jambalaya emits a red hue, and Creole gumbo does as well because of the tomato base. Like Jambalaya, there are subtle Cajun and Creole differences. Gumbo is typically distinguished on the basis of what is used as a thickening agent typically okra, roux, file powder, or sometimes the combination of all these three are used during gumbo making. Jambalaya is more of a stew, thanks to the fact that the rice is cooked with the meal.

Cajun jambalaya will also have a smokier taste to it, as the meat is usually browned in a cast iron pot. Instead, they used abundant tomatoes, converting the sun-gold yellow we all know as a signature of paella to a ruddy brown. It is a thick soup, though, thanks to the use of a roux or okra. Both found roots in Louisiana, though suffer from somewhat muddy origin stories. Gumbo, jambalaya, and étouffée are popular Louisianian dishes other than Muffuletta and Po-boy. Similarly, gumbo has origins in Africa, France, Spain, and the Native American Choctaw people. Jambalaya originated from the French Quarter of New Orleans and considered as a culinary cousin of Spanish Paella, Gumbo is a thick spicy stew that often contains seafood, sausage, chicken, okra, and other vegetables, served on a bed of rice, Jambalaya is a traditional Creole dish that combines rice with vegetables and some type of meat usually chicken and andouille sausage, It is thickened with either okra, ground sassafras leaves, or a dark roux, Most cook simmer gumbo for three hours minimum, Rice is cooked separately and served with stew, Jambalaya is a stew that is cooked with a rice. Suffice it to say that, whatever its origin, gumbo became a staple of southern Louisiana in the 19th century. Prepare them all, one by one, and find the flavors (and ingredients) that work best for you. However, it does not include okra, which Cajun gumbo uses. Gumbo z’herbes is different from other gumbos in that it is only made with vegetables and seasonings. Amazon Associates Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

It has origins in West Africa, Spain, and France.

Gumbo is a dish that boasts a tasty broth that is thickened by either a dark roux, okra, or ground sassafras leaves.
Gumbo is usually classified as a soup. Gumbo is more like a soup that is served over a small serving of rice (unlike Jambalaya the rice is not cooked in the same pan) and is believed to have originated in New Orleans in the 18th century. The easiest and main difference between the Gumbo and Jambalaya is the addition of rice in the process of cooking. We might even add your comments to the article! Because most of the ingredients are green in color, the result is a rich, green stew packed full of both flavor and nutrients. Sausage is popular in both, although chicken, shrimp, crab, and beef can also be used in either dish. As mentioned above, jambalaya leans on a tomato base — along with the Holy Trinity — for its rich, earthy base. Cajun jambalaya usually has a brownish tone to it.

This is a meat and vegetable dish that uses a wide assortment of protein. This site contains affiliate links to third-party brands and products. Different pockets of the Cajun and Creole communities of the South have updated (read: enhanced) these 19th centuries staples to suit their pantries, tastes, and the availability of ingredients.

Gumbo z’herbes is traditionally made during Lent. The result of this dish is a softer color because the rice maintains its white color. Gumbo requires a thickening agent, such as a roux or even okra, while jambalaya uses the rice to thicken up the sauce. Meats and seafood are added and sautéed, then mixed with rice and enough stock to plump up the rice kernels. For starters, gumbo is generally not tomato-based, leaning on a “low and slow” sauté of the Holy Trinity before dark roux and beef stock are added. While both are served with rice, gumbo cooks the rice separately, and then pours the soup-like dish over top, while jambalaya cooks the rice in with the dish. While very similar Cajun/Creole dishes, gumbo and jambalaya have distinct origins. And yes, they do have many things in common: rice, seafood, sausage. Creole gumbo is all about the addition of okra. They incorporate good protein and often plenty of vegetables. Other vegetables that can be added include carrots, tomatoes, and okra, depending on the recipe. A meatless variation of gumbo also exists — owing largely to Catholics who were forbidden from eating meat on Fridays during Lent. Gumbo is thickened by the addition of okra, sassafras, or flour while Jambalaya is thickened by the addition of rice alone. Malt vs Shake – Know the Major Difference. While early differences in the dish’s preparation were limited to the inclusion of tomatoes (or not), these days you’ll find everything from sweet potatoes and chipotle peppers to artichokes and tarragon mixing up the pot. Instead, a dark roux is used to thicken the dish. Finally, jambalaya also includes rice, which is normally cooked into the meal, for a one-pot dish. While it starts with meat, such as sausage, ham, chicken, shrimp, or crab, it also adds okra as a thickening agent. Both gumbo and jambalaya are stapled foods in Louisiana. The dish is then simmered until the vegetables and rice are tender and meat is cooked through. And much like the settlers to southern Louisiana did when originating gumbo and jambalaya, so, too, do devotee across the U.S., utilizing ingredients most familiar and accessible to them. First, gumbo. The thickener commonly used in gumbo, filé powder (dried and pulverized sassafras leaves), is said to be of Native American origin, which puts the dish’s European foundation into doubt. Gumbo and Jambalaya? Praesent vestibulum dapibus nibh. The first step involves cooking the meat that includes chicken, sausage, or both and vegetables such as celery, onions, and peppers in a pan. Rice is used in this dish but is cooked separately. Next, jambalaya. Hot peppers often play a role, again depending on the recipe and the taste of who is eating. Origin. Don’t worry; we’ll point you in the right direction. Cajun jambalaya starts with cooking meat, then onion, celery, and pepper; it’s finished with stock and rice. (For more on the Holy Trinity, go here.)

Jambalaya is a dish that has a rich history. But there are key differences. Gumbo is more like a soup consisting of veggies, okra, meat, or shellfish that is served over or with a small serving of rice. Usually, basmati rice is used because it can be cooked longer without becoming too mushy. What is Gumbo? The addition of seafood and meat in various cuisines is a norm. However, it is poured over rice to create the final presentation. In short, these dishes are so versatile they practically beg for variation.

However, it is now recognized as the state cuisine of Louisiana. Gumbo is more of a soup than a stew, although there are many variations. One of the most significant aspects of gumbo is the cooking time, many cooks simmer gumbo for a minimum of three hours in order to help the stew thicken and to let all flavors blend together and create a rich and flavorful stock. Then there’s the issue of media misdirection, regularly countered by NOLA natives; as locals claim, quick-assuming, heavy-handed media too often — and falsely — assume Creole and Cajun dishes are pretty much all French in origin. Gumbo and jambalaya use a mixture of meat and seafood.

Gumbo and jambalaya both use meat and vegetables, as well as unique seasonings to produce scrumptious dishes. Jambalaya is not immune to widespread culinary experimentation either. Gumbo and jambalaya have a lot of flavors that need to be stewed fully.

What’s for dinner tonight? Gumbo has a much longer cooking time that means all the flavors are more evenly distributed between all the ingredients in the stew while in Jambalaya the cooking time is much lower. The first time I mad Jambalaya, I made it from scratch, and used green pepper, clery, onion, garlic, one small chili pepper (it really was too hot) seed the pepper, scallions and parsley, andouille sausage, shrimp and extra long grain rice, chili powder, bay leaf salt and pepper, chicken stock. This story of this dish is decidedly more European: In the 18th century, intermingling Spanish in NOLA’s French Quarter tried to make their native paella but without costly saffron. While the dish was content to remain both regional and humble, the governor pronounced Gonzales, Louisiana “The Jambalaya Capital of the World” in 1968, inaugurating the annual Jambalaya Festival and capturing the attention of chefs the world over. Send us a note at editor@southtosoutheast.com. A dizzying blend of multiple culinary influences and ingredients — including African okra, French bouillabaisse, and local seafood — gumbo is thought to be the result of immigrants attempting to recreate familiar cuisine with a whole host of new ingredients. While you can easily find Cajun jambalaya throughout Louisiana, it is originally from the rural areas of the state. The first known instance of gumbo in a cookbook was 1802 while jambalaya didn’t show up in print until 1837. Read on to find out what makes these two meals so similar and so different. Praesent vestibulum dapibus nibh. These dishes have spicy and smoky flavors. Gumbo is usually classified as a soup. Creole jambalaya shares similar characteristics of Cajun jambalaya, except for one important ingredient. You can add a wide variety of vegetables, although more common ones include spinach, turnips, cabbage, collards, and chard. The gumbo stew is normally served over top of the rice. Finally, a thickener is used, which is either okra or a dark roux. Most of the credit for gumbo’s popularization should go to Paul Prudhomme, however; the New Orleans culinary great wowed us with his rendition at K-Paul’s Louisiana Kitchen, teaching Americans that simple foods often have their own sophisticated appeal. It wasn’t until the 1970s, when the U.S. Senate Dining Room added it to their menu, that it gained some notoriety.
There are so many recipes for gumbo and jambalaya available online, it’s hard to know where to start. Expect any recipe to require you to cook the meal for a few hours at a low temperature so that everything blends nicely. The locals of New Orleans are a unique blend of French, Spanish, African, German, and Native Americans that gave birth to a number of Creole dishes including Gumbo and Jambalaya. However, with white jambalaya, the rice is cooked separately and only added at the end.